How to Segment Businesses for Commercial Insurance Campaigns

Commercial insurance segmentation can help providers divide a broad business market into smaller groups with more similar risks, insurance needs and buying characteristics.

Rather than approaching every business with the same message, segmentation allows insurers to build campaigns around factors such as:

• Industry
• Employee numbers
• Turnover
• Business activity
• Number of locations
• Commercial premises
• Vehicle fleets
• Insurance product
• Decision-maker role
• Renewal timing

The aim is to create prospect groups that are easier to understand, easier to target and more relevant to the insurance proposition being promoted.

Start with the Insurance Product

Before segmenting the market, decide which product or policy area you want to promote.

Potential commercial insurance products include:

• Employers’ liability
• Public liability
• Professional indemnity
• Commercial property
• Fleet insurance
• Cyber insurance
• Directors and officers insurance
• Product liability
• Business interruption
• Commercial combined insurance
• Contractors insurance
• Motor trade insurance

Different products naturally require different segments.

A fleet insurance campaign, for example, should not use the same audience as a professional indemnity campaign.

Segment by Industry

Industry is one of the most useful ways to divide commercial insurance prospects.

Potential sectors include:

• Manufacturing
• Construction
• Engineering
• Transport and logistics
• Professional services
• Technology
• Recruitment
• Wholesale
• Property
• Facilities management
• Hospitality
• Motor trade
• Healthcare
• Retail

Each industry has different operational characteristics and risk exposures.

Separating sectors can therefore make campaign messaging more relevant.

Break Broad Industries into Smaller Groups

Large industries can contain very different businesses.

Manufacturing, for example, might include:

• Food manufacturers
• Metal manufacturers
• Engineering companies
• Packaging manufacturers
• Furniture manufacturers
• Machinery manufacturers

Construction could be divided into:

• Main contractors
• Civil engineering companies
• Electrical contractors
• Plumbing contractors
• Roofing contractors
• Groundworks businesses

Smaller segments can help insurers create more focused prospect lists.

Segment by Business Activity

Formal industry classification does not always provide enough detail.

Business activity can help refine the market further.

For example, you might identify companies that:

• Operate fleets
• Manufacture products
• Work at customer premises
• Provide professional advice
• Manage commercial property
• Hold sensitive customer data
• Employ field workers
• Operate multiple sites

These activities can point towards particular insurance requirements.

Segment by Company Size

Employee numbers can help distinguish smaller businesses from larger commercial accounts.

Possible bands include:

• 5 to 19 employees
• 20 to 49 employees
• 50 to 99 employees
• 100 to 249 employees
• 250+ employees

Different company sizes can have different:

• Premium potential
• Risk complexity
• Buying structures
• Policy requirements
• Decision-makers

This makes company size a useful segmentation variable.

Segment by Turnover

Turnover provides another way to separate businesses by scale.

Potential groups might include:

• Under £1 million
• £1 million to £5 million
• £5 million to £10 million
• £10 million to £50 million
• £50 million+

The most useful turnover bands will depend on the insurance product and target account size.

Turnover should usually be considered alongside industry and employee numbers.

Combine Employee Numbers and Turnover

Using both criteria can produce stronger segments.

For example:

• Manufacturers with 50 to 249 employees and £5 million+ turnover
• Professional services firms with 20 to 99 employees and £1 million+ turnover
• Logistics businesses with 100+ employees and £10 million+ turnover

These combinations create more defined prospect audiences.

Segment by Geography

Geographic segmentation can support:

• Regional sales teams
• Territory management
• Local campaigns
• Regional events
• Face-to-face meetings

Potential geographic filters include:

• Country
• Region
• County
• City
• Postcode area

National providers can still use location to organise campaigns and compare performance.

Segment by Number of Locations

Multi-site businesses can have more complex insurance requirements.

Potential prospect groups include:

• Single-site businesses
• Businesses with 2 to 5 locations
• Businesses with 6 to 20 locations
• Large multi-site organisations

Multiple locations can increase exposure across:

• Property
• Employees
• Vehicles
• Liability
• Business interruption

This can make multi-site segmentation particularly useful for larger commercial risks.

Segment by Commercial Premises

The type of premises can help indicate likely insurance requirements.

Potential groups include businesses operating:

• Factories
• Warehouses
• Offices
• Shops
• Hotels
• Workshops
• Distribution centres

A factory-based manufacturer can have a very different risk profile from an office-based consultancy.

Premises can therefore help refine industry segmentation.

Segment by Fleet Exposure

Fleet size can be particularly useful for commercial motor campaigns.

Possible groups include:

• Small fleets
• Medium fleets
• Large fleets
• Multi-depot fleets

Relevant target sectors may include:

• Logistics
• Construction
• Facilities management
• Engineering
• Wholesale
• Field service companies

Fleet exposure can help distinguish higher-value opportunities.

Segment by Insurance Product

One business may potentially need several commercial insurance products.

You can create separate campaign segments for:

• Fleet insurance
• Cyber insurance
• Professional indemnity
• Commercial property
• Contractors insurance
• Commercial combined
• Directors and officers insurance

Each segment can then receive product-specific messaging.

Segment by Likely Risk

Insurance campaigns can also be structured around the underlying exposure.

For example:

Property Risk

Target businesses with:

• Factories
• Warehouses
• Hotels
• Retail premises
• Multiple commercial sites

Fleet Risk

Target businesses with:

• Delivery vehicles
• Service vans
• HGVs
• Multi-vehicle operations

Professional Risk

Target organisations that:

• Provide advice
• Deliver consultancy
• Offer specialist professional services

Cyber Risk

Target businesses that:

• Hold customer data
• Depend heavily on technology
• Operate online
• Handle sensitive information

Risk-led segmentation can make the proposition more specific.

Segment by Decision-Maker

Different job roles can receive different campaign messaging.

Potential contacts include:

• Business Owners
• Managing Directors
• Finance Directors
• CFOs
• Financial Controllers
• Risk Managers
• Operations Directors
• Procurement Managers
• Fleet Managers
• IT Directors

A Finance Director may care about different issues from a Fleet Manager or IT Director.

Decision-maker segmentation can therefore improve relevance.

Match Decision-Makers to Company Size

Small businesses may be segmented towards:

• Business Owners
• Managing Directors

Medium-sized businesses could focus on:

• Finance Directors
• Financial Controllers
• Operations Directors

Larger organisations may involve:

• CFOs
• Risk Managers
• Procurement
• Specialist departmental leaders

This helps prevent poor job-role targeting.

Match Decision-Makers to Insurance Product

Product type can also determine the best contact.

Fleet Insurance

Potential contacts:

• Fleet Manager
• Transport Manager
• Operations Director
• Finance Director

Cyber Insurance

Relevant contacts:

• IT Director
• Information Security Manager
• Finance Director
• Risk Manager

Professional Indemnity

Potential contacts:

• Managing Director
• Finance Director
• Commercial Director

Commercial Property

Relevant decision-makers:

• Finance Director
• Facilities Manager
• Property Manager

This creates more precise campaign segments.

Segment by Renewal Timing

Renewal timing can be one of the most valuable ways to segment commercial insurance prospects.

Possible groups include:

• Renewal within 3 months
• Renewal within 4 to 6 months
• Renewal within 7 to 12 months
• Recently renewed
• Renewal unknown

A strong-fit prospect approaching renewal may deserve more immediate attention.

Businesses with later renewals can remain within a longer-term pipeline.

Combine Account Fit with Renewal Timing

Timing should not be used alone.

A poor-fit business renewing next month may still be less valuable than a strong-fit business renewing in six months.

Consider combining:

• Industry
• Company size
• Premium potential
• Risk fit
• Renewal timing

This can create a more useful prioritisation model.

Create High-Priority Segments

A high-priority segment might include businesses with:

• Strong underwriting fit
• Suitable company size
• High potential premium
• Relevant decision-maker
• Known renewal date
• Multiple insurance requirements

These accounts can justify more personalised outreach.

Create Mid-Priority Segments

Medium-priority prospects may:

• Match the target market
• Have suitable size
• Need relevant cover
• Lack known renewal timing

These businesses can be placed into qualification campaigns.

Create Lower-Priority Segments

Broader prospects might:

• Match basic industry criteria
• Have lower premium potential
• Require more qualification

They can still be useful, but may receive more scalable outreach.

Segment by Existing Customer Similarity

Lookalike segmentation can help identify businesses resembling strong customers.

For example, if profitable customers are:

• Engineering firms
• 50 to 200 employees
• £5 million+ turnover
• Multi-policy accounts

you can build a segment of similar UK businesses.

This can be more useful than relying on broad sector targeting.

Segment by Existing Broker Status

Where qualification information is available, prospects might also be grouped by:

• Existing broker known
• Existing broker unknown
• Direct relationship with insurer
• Broker review planned
• Happy with current arrangement

This information can help determine future outreach.

Segment by Current Provider

Knowing the current insurer or broker can create useful sales intelligence.

Potential segments might include:

• Competitor A users
• Competitor B users
• Unknown provider
• No broker identified

This can help sales teams understand switching opportunities.

Segment by Policy Complexity

Commercial accounts can vary significantly in complexity.

Possible groups include:

Simple Accounts

• Few policies
• Single site
• Smaller workforce

Mid-Complexity Accounts

• Several policies
• Larger workforce
• Multiple locations

Complex Accounts

• Multi-site
• Large fleet
• Several insurance products
• Risk management function
• Procurement involvement

Different sales approaches can then be used for each group.

Segment by Premium Potential

Where sufficient information is available, prospects can be grouped by estimated account value.

Potential tiers include:

• Lower-value accounts
• Mid-market accounts
• High-value commercial accounts

The exact thresholds will depend on your business.

Higher-value accounts may justify more research and multi-channel outreach.

Build Product-Specific Campaigns

Segmenting by product can help keep messages focused.

For example:

Fleet Insurance Campaign

Target:

• Logistics
• Construction
• Facilities management
• Fleet Managers
• Operations Directors

Cyber Insurance Campaign

Target:

• Technology
• Professional services
• Financial services
• IT Directors
• Finance Directors

Professional Indemnity Campaign

Target:

• Consultants
• Accountants
• Architects
• Technology businesses
• Managing Directors
• Finance Directors

Separate campaigns can produce clearer propositions.

Build Industry-Specific Campaigns

Industry-led segmentation can make messaging more relevant.

For example:

Manufacturing

Potential themes:

• Property
• Product liability
• Business interruption
• Employee risk

Construction

Relevant themes:

• Liability
• Contractors risks
• Plant
• Vehicles

Professional Services

Potential themes:

• Professional indemnity
• Cyber
• Directors and officers

Industry context can improve the quality of outbound messaging.

Build Decision-Maker-Specific Campaigns

The same business segment can be approached differently depending on the recipient.

Finance Director

Potential messaging could focus on:

• Insurance expenditure
• Financial exposure
• Renewal
• Business continuity

Risk Manager

Relevant areas might include:

• Risk exposure
• Claims
• Coverage
• Risk management

Operations Director

Useful themes could include:

• Operational risks
• Employees
• Assets
• Continuity

Fleet Manager

Potential focus:

• Vehicles
• Drivers
• Claims
• Fleet changes

This can make campaign messaging more specific.

Use Cold Email for Segmented Campaigns

Cold email can provide a scalable way to test different commercial insurance segments.

Rather than sending one generic campaign, create separate audiences.

For example:

• Finance Directors at manufacturers with 50+ employees
• Fleet Managers at logistics companies
• Managing Directors at professional services firms
• IT Directors at technology companies

Each group can receive a more relevant proposition.

Use Telemarketing to Refine Segments

Telephone outreach can reveal whether the segment is genuinely strong.

Calls can help establish:

• Correct decision-maker
• Current broker
• Current insurer
• Renewal timing
• Products held
• Future review plans

This information can be used to refine the segment further.

Use LinkedIn for Account Research

LinkedIn can support segmentation by helping identify:

• Company size
• Decision-makers
• Department structure
• New appointments
• Growth
• Additional locations

This can add context to the underlying prospect data.

Segment by Buying Signals

Business changes can indicate a need to review insurance.

Potential signals include:

• New premises
• Recruitment
• Fleet growth
• Acquisitions
• New contracts
• International expansion
• New senior decision-makers

A prospect showing one or more buying signals may deserve higher priority.

Use New Premises as a Segment

Businesses opening or acquiring premises may need to review:

• Property insurance
• Contents cover
• Public liability
• Business interruption
• Employers’ liability

A “new premises” segment can therefore support property-related campaigns.

Use Fleet Growth as a Segment

Companies adding vehicles may be relevant for:

• Fleet insurance
• Motor trade cover
• Commercial vehicle insurance

Potential sectors include logistics, construction and facilities management.

This segment can be prioritised where fleet growth is recent.

Use New Contracts as a Segment

Large contract wins can change insurance requirements.

Potential implications include:

• Increased liability limits
• Professional indemnity
• Cyber requirements
• Additional employees
• Contract-specific insurance

This can be useful within construction, professional services and facilities management.

Use New Decision-Makers as a Segment

New senior employees may review existing suppliers and policies.

Potential roles include:

• Finance Director
• CFO
• Risk Director
• Operations Director
• Procurement Director

A new appointment can provide a useful reason to research the account.

Segment for Multi-Channel Outreach

Different segments may justify different levels of sales activity.

For example:

High-Value Segment

Use:

• Personalised email
• Telephone
• LinkedIn
• Account research

Mid-Market Segment

Use:

• Segmented email
• Telephone follow-up
• LinkedIn where useful

Broader Segment

Use:

• Scalable email
• Selective telephone qualification

This helps align sales effort with potential account value.

Record Segment Membership in Your CRM

Prospects can belong to several useful groups.

For example, a business might be:

• Manufacturing
• 100 to 249 employees
• Multi-site
• Fleet exposure
• Renewal within six months
• Finance Director identified

Recording these attributes makes future campaign selection easier.

Track Performance by Segment

Every segment should be measurable.

Useful outcomes include:

• Replies
• Conversations
• Decision-makers identified
• Renewal dates identified
• Quotes
• Policies won
• Premium value
• Retention

This helps determine which audiences are worth keeping.

Compare Industry Segments

Different industries can produce very different results.

For example:

• Manufacturing may produce larger premiums.
• Logistics could create stronger fleet opportunities.
• Technology may generate more cyber prospects.
• Professional services could produce more PI conversations.

Use commercial results to decide which sectors deserve greater attention.

Compare Company-Size Segments

Different employee bands may produce different account values and sales cycles.

Smaller businesses might:

• Be easier to reach
• Make decisions faster

Larger businesses can offer:

• Higher premiums
• More policies
• Greater complexity
• Longer sales cycles

The strongest size segment will depend on your proposition.

Compare Renewal Segments

Renewal timing can also be measured.

Compare prospects approached:

• 1 to 3 months before renewal
• 4 to 6 months before renewal
• 7 to 12 months before renewal

Your own results can help identify the most productive contact window.

Compare Decision-Maker Segments

Track results across:

• Business Owners
• Managing Directors
• Finance Directors
• Risk Managers
• Operations Directors
• Fleet Managers
• IT Directors

The strongest role can vary considerably by product.

Compare Product Segments

Measure results for:

• Fleet
• Cyber
• Professional indemnity
• Commercial property
• Commercial combined
• Contractors insurance

Some products may produce stronger conversion, premium or retention.

Use this information when allocating campaign resources.

Remove Weak Segments

Not every initial segment will perform well.

A group may generate:

• Few relevant conversations
• Low premium potential
• Poor underwriting fit
• Weak conversion

Reduce or remove weak segments rather than continuing to target them because they contain large numbers of businesses.

Expand Strong Segments

If one audience consistently produces strong results, build on it.

For example, if medium-sized manufacturers generate good commercial accounts, you could expand into:

• Similar manufacturing subsectors
• Nearby employee bands
• Additional geographic areas
• Related decision-maker roles

This allows segmentation to develop using real sales performance.

Avoid Over-Segmenting

Too many filters can create tiny prospect audiences.

If you require an exact:

• Industry
• Employee size
• Turnover
• Location
• Product
• Job role
• Renewal period

the market may become unnecessarily small.

Focus on criteria that materially affect customer fit.

Avoid Under-Segmenting

The opposite problem is sending every prospect the same message.

A generic “UK businesses” campaign offers little relevance.

Even basic segmentation by:

• Industry
• Company size
• Product
• Decision-maker

can make campaigns significantly more focused.

Build a Repeatable Segmentation Process

A practical commercial insurance segmentation process could include:

• Choose the insurance product.
• Select suitable industries.
• Apply company-size criteria.
• Add turnover where useful.
• Consider business activity and risk.
• Identify relevant decision-makers.
• Build initial prospect segments.
• Add renewal timing where available.
• Prioritise stronger accounts.
• Run email, telephone and LinkedIn campaigns.
• Measure results by segment.
• Refine the audience.

This creates a structured approach to commercial insurance targeting.

You can learn more about our Lead Generation for Insurance Providers services.

Summary

Commercial insurance segmentation helps providers divide a broad business market into smaller, more relevant prospect groups.

Industry, employee numbers, turnover, geography, premises, fleet exposure and business activity can all help identify companies with similar risk characteristics.

Decision-maker and insurance-product segmentation can then make outreach more relevant to the person receiving it.

Renewal timing adds another valuable layer by helping distinguish businesses that may be approaching a buying window from longer-term prospects.

The strongest approach is to test different segments against real commercial outcomes such as quote opportunities, policies won, premium value and retention.

Over time, this allows insurers to concentrate lead generation activity on the combinations of industry, company size, risk profile, decision-maker and timing that produce the strongest results.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is commercial insurance segmentation?

Commercial insurance segmentation is the process of dividing businesses into smaller groups based on characteristics such as industry, company size, risk profile, insurance product and renewal timing.

Which criteria should insurers use to segment businesses?

Useful criteria include industry, employee numbers, turnover, geography, premises, number of sites, fleet exposure, business activity, decision-maker and insurance renewal date.

Should commercial insurers segment by industry?

Yes. Different industries have different operational risks and insurance requirements, making industry one of the most useful starting points for segmentation.

Can insurers segment prospects by insurance product?

Yes. Separate segments can be built for fleet, cyber, professional indemnity, commercial property, commercial combined and other products.

Why is renewal timing useful for segmentation?

Businesses approaching renewal can be prioritised for more immediate outreach, while later renewals can remain within a longer-term sales pipeline.

Should insurers segment by decision-maker?

Yes. Finance Directors, Risk Managers, Operations Directors, Fleet Managers and IT Directors can have different priorities, so messaging can be adapted accordingly.

How should insurers measure segment performance?

Track qualified conversations, renewal dates identified, quotes, policies won, premium value and retention across each prospect segment.

Data & Lead Generation Services

RD Marketing provides bespoke B2B data lists and fully managed lead generation services to help businesses build pipeline and drive revenue growth. These include:

• Automated Email Campaigns
• LinkedIn Automation
• Industry Databases
• Job Role Databases
• Email Lists
• Telemarketing Data
• Direct Mail Data

Follow the links above or get in touch for more information – [email protected] / +44 191 406 6399